Apparently, I'm not the only long-time fan, to be jarred by episode 12. I had this comment
"I've been a fan for over thirty years, and didn't like that episode very much. I thought it was done purely for shock value and also so Russell could get his rocks off by upsetting the fans, while tying up some loose ends. I thought it was very sloppy, and if it weren't for Steven M. coming into the picture next year, I might have considered walking away from the programme.
I'm not sure how a brilliant writer like Davies manages to end his tenure on Doctor Who by writing such insipid drivel. He might as well start writing comic books.
Of course, the dumbed down masses probably loved all the shockers, I suppose. Anyone who loves programmes like Big Brother, probably wouldn't know a bad script if it had "bad script" written all over the walls of sets."---Phil
Well, as I replied to "Phil," I KNOW neither Davies nor Tennant will care about the personal effect this had on me and other fans.
Doctor Who does pander a little to the masses, but mostly it never did--which is what drew me to the show. Episode 12 was such shameful pandering....disgusted the hell out of me. Oh, no fault of the actors, I suppose, they have to do the script they're given. Except Tennant...that script stunk, and I can't believe he was so blind in love with Davies that he didn't notice that.
I wasn't prepared for such a shock or such a "bad" surprise. Of course, being ill and mentally depressed, probably made the impact last weekend, worse then it might have been, before. I certainly am not as in love with it as I was, as it really DID feel to me, like an old, valued and trusted friend, slapping me in the face for no reason.
I'd begun to feel as if I was the only one who felt this way, but apparently I'm not entirely alone.
______________________________________________________________________________________
In the world of Doctor Who rumours:
Actors rumoured to replace Tennant:
Rhys Ifans from Wales is the New Dr.
Some guy named Robert Carlyle is the new Dr.
John Sims is the New Doctor (tho how he could play BOTH the Dr and The Master without messing with suspension of disbelief or continuity, is beyond me)
Donna is going to be the new Doctor (oh, sounds kinky)
ALSO:
Rose is really a Dalek
Donna’s going to save them all but lose her life in the process (votex thing again)
Rose is going to replace Donna as the new companion

David Tennat: the poster boy for sexy nerds--see guys? there is hope for you.






